Lynn Buhl - Good for the Tittabawassee?

-----------

Senate Rejects Buhl Nomination

Ehrlich: Democratic Leadership Twisted Arms To Defeat Buhl

POSTED: 8:58 am EST March 11, 2003
UPDATED: 8:40 pm EST March 11, 2003
ANNAPOLIS, Md. -- The Senate voted down Gov. Bob Ehrlich's appointment of Lynn Buhl to be the state environmental secretary.
 
WBAL-TV 11 News reporter David Collins was present during the vote and said 26 senators voted against Buhl's nomination while 21 voted for her appointment. He said seven Democratic senators and all 14 Republican senators supported Buhl's nomination -- while 26 Democrats voted against her.

In a written statement, Buhl said she was disappointed with the vote. "I want to thank Gov. Ehrlich and Lt. Gov. Steele for the loyalty and strong support of my nomination," she wrote. "I also want to thank Senators of both parties who voted for me, and the many Marylanders who supported me".

Earlier in the day, both sides of the nomination process said they could not declare victory.

Republicans gave unanimous support to Buhl and Senate Minority Leader Lowell Stoltzfus led the charge.

"Lynn Buhl is qualified individual to be secretary of the Department of the Environment and she's going to be rejected because it's a party call," Stoltzfus said.

"It is a sad day and it's going to be an even sadder day come the rest of this term," Cecil and Harford County Sen. Nancy Jacobs, R-District 34, said.

"This candidate, this designee, is willing to open that two-way negotiation. The door was slammed shut," Minority Whip Sen. Andrew Harris, R-District 7, said.

The 26 Democratic senators who voted against Buhl's nomination said they question her credentials, citing a lack of management experience and her lack of commitment to protecting the environment.
 
Montgomery County Sen. Brian Frosh, D-District 16, made an analogy between Buhl's former job in the Michigan Department of the Environment and the 1960s TV show "The Adams Family."

"If you are looking for a baby sitter for your beloved children [and] someone comes in, she looks good, seems nice and her past employer is the Adams family, and you say to her, 'You know, when you worked for the Adams family, did you notice anything strange about [them]?' And she says, 'No,'" Frosh said.

Ehrlich said he's disappointed and suggested that there was serious arm-twisting by the Senate's Democratic leadership that killed Buhl's nomination.
"I guess the three votes who supported her in committee had their arms twisted. And look, this is split government and not everything is going to be easy," Ehrlich said.

Democrats offered a compromise over the weekend to put Buhl on probation for a year. The governor rejected it and Republicans said that instead of being a deal, the Democrat's suggestion was an insult.

Buhl was a former midlevel manager in the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality who lost her job after the change from a Republican to a Democratic administration last November. Before that, she was a lawyer for the federal Environmental Protection Agency and DaimlerChrysler Corp.

With Buhl defeated, it was the first time a governor's nominee for a cabinet position has been rejected. Democrats point out, however, that Senate Republicans voted against two of former Gov. Parris Glendening's appointments but didn't have enough votes to reject the nominations.

The governor said he will not submit another nominee. Instead, the state Department of the Environment will now be run by the deputy secretary who is, ironically, someone environmentalists oppose more than Buhl, Collins reported.

Ehrlich previously said if she is not confirmed, it will be bad for him and for Senate Democrats, WBAL-TV 11 NEWS reported.
===============================
AND:
===============================
 

Lynn Buhl

Title Deputy Assistant Administrator 
Organization U.S. EPA 


Lynn Buhl is the Deputy Assistant Administrator of EPA’s Office of Enforcement and Compliance Assurance (OECA) in Washington, DC. OECA’s mission is to improve the environment and protect public health by ensuring compliance with the nation’s environmental laws, preventing pollution, and promoting environmental stewardship. As Deputy Assistant Administrator, Ms. Buhl serves as the deputy political official for EPA’s enforcement and compliance assurance office, with approximately 3,300 environmental professionals and an annual budget of more than $500 million. Ms. Buhl has a broad range of environmental experience. From 2003 until 2006, she advised Maryland Governor Robert Ehrlich on environmental and policy issues in several different capacities. She served most recently as the Deputy Secretary of the Department of Natural Resources, where her responsibilities included policy development, program adjustments, communications issues and personnel matters. Prior to joining the Department of Natural Resources, she served as the Acting Secretary of the Department of the Environment, and later as co-chair of the Governor’s team responsible for developing and guiding legislation to reform Maryland’s contaminated site cleanup program. Ms. Buhl previously worked as the Director of the Southeast Offices of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality from 1999 to 2002, and as Senior Staff Counsel for Environmental Legal Affairs at DaimlerChrysler Corporation from 1988 until 1999. In her eleven years with Chrysler, she was responsible for Superfund and Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) defense work, voluntary remediation at company-owned sites, facility deactivation issues, real estate transactions and environmental due diligence. During her tenure, Chrysler became recognized nationally as a leader in brownfield redevelopment. In addition, in the mid-1990s, she was the spokesperson on Superfund reform for the American Automobile Manufacturers Association and in that capacity represented the industry in federal legislative negotiations and in testimony before Congress. During the same time frame, Ms. Buhl served as trustee and chairman of the Higgins Lake Foundation, a non-profit organization dedicated to preserving and protecting the quality and beauty of Higgins Lake, Michigan. The foundation raised $1 million in endowment funds during that period and began addressing sources of nutrient loading into the lake, including surface water runoff, septic systems and erosion due to high winter lake levels. In 1995, Ms. Buhl was recognized by the Environmental Law Institute as a “Person to Know”in the environmental field.
===============================
AND
===============================
Buhl Foes Confident on Senate Vote; Md. GOP Seeking Ways to Save Face
[FINAL Edition] The Washington Post - Washington, D.C.
Author: Lori Montgomery
Date: Mar 6, 2003
Start Page: B.01
Section: METRO

With 14 Republican senators, [Robert L. Ehrlich Jr.] needs at least 10 Democrats to save the nomination. Yesterday, Ehrlich's appointments secretary, Lawrence J. Hogan Jr., and former Republican senator Martin G. Madden worked the chamber as [Lynn Buhl] hustled to meetings with undecided Democrats, including Katherine A. Klausmeier (Baltimore County), George W. Della Jr. (Baltimore) and P.J. Hogan (Montgomery). Buhl was scheduled to meet today with a fourth undecided Senate Democrat, Gloria G. Lawlah (Prince George's).

Asked about the possibility that Republicans could try to save Buhl's position by maneuvering the nomination into legislative limbo, Madden said: "We are preparing for all eventualities. But the governor is totally committed to Secretary Buhl."

Only five Democrats declared an intention to support Buhl: Thomas M. Middleton (Charles), James E. DeGrange Sr. (Anne Arundel), John C. Astle (Anne Arundel), Edward J. Kasemeyer (Baltimore County) and Norman R. Stone Jr. (Baltimore County). All five said that Buhl is qualified and that environmentalists have failed to make a compelling case for denying Ehrlich the right to assemble his own team.

===============================
AND
===============================
The Two Stories of Lynn Buhl

Maryland Senate Will Write the Next Chapter

There’s two sides to every story.

Gov. Robert Ehrlich says his nominee to head Maryland’s Department of the Environment, former mid-tier Michigan environmental bureaucrat Lynn Buhl, is “a business-savvy lawyer and environmentalist who will effectively strike a careful balance between a healthy environment and a healthy economy.”
That’s one side of the story.

The other side is that Buhl’s the wrong woman for the job
.
“She’s not sufficiently experienced, not sufficiently familiar with Maryland’s unique environmental problems — and she arrives here from one of the most anti-environmental state agencies in the country,” counters environmental activist and lawyer Terry Harris.

Harris, of Baltimore, directs the Cleanup Coalition, organized in 1998 in response to the plight of Wagner Point, a Baltimore neighborhood languishing amid a circle of chemical plants. The entire community was eventually relocated. The coalition has since helped other neighborhoods with emergency planning and brownfield clean-up, Harris says.

Other environmental organizations, like League of Conservation Voters, are “concerned about Buhl and the culture she comes from in terms of the future of our Maryland agency when it comes to strong enforcement,” says League executive director Sue Brown.

The Cleanup Coalition is a small player on Maryland’s environmental scene, but it’s taken its concern to the plate.

“This is the most important position on the environment in Maryland,” says Harris, “and she’s just not right for the job.”

Of his talking campaign to keep Buhl out of Maryland Department of the Environment, Harris says: “You go to where the choke point is and that’s the Senate,”

He’s making his case this week in advance of the Senate Executive Nominations Committee’s consideration of Buhl on March 3. Ten votes in committee would take the nomination to the entire senate with a negative recommendation. On the Senate floor, Harris would need 24 no’s. Then, he hopes, “the nomination won’t go forward.”

Harris bases his objections to Buhl on “the Michigan record,” which, he says, “has been horrible for the environment.”

Back to the other side of the story.

Harris’ is the kind of “kneejerk reaction,” that, says Lt. Gov. Michael Steele, provoked him to label opponents of Buhl’s nomination “whiners.”

Reprising a linguistic directness of Spiro Agnew, Maryland’s last Republican governor, practiced as Richard Nixon’s vice president, Lt. Steele said “You are a whiner when you base your objections to a woman you don’t know on [the reports of] groups against her out in Michigan.

“Give her one or two years,” he told Bay Weekly in an interview, “and I’m sure you’ll see that she’ll adapt and that all the whining was unnecessary.”
There are two sides to every story, but only one will prevail. As soon as next week, we could know if Lynn Buhl will be given her chance.


Source: TRW

For additional articles like this one, go to the Tittabawassee River Watch web site www.trwnews.net. for complete coverage of the Tittabawassee River Dow Chemical dioxin contamination saga.. The source organization's web site link is listed above. The Newspaper / Media page of our site contains an extensive archive of media articles dating back to January 2002. The Newspaper / Media page may be accessed by scrolling down to the bottom of the CONTENTS section and clicking on the Newspaper/Media link.